Valentine's Day Gifts for Your Crush

Surprise your crush with one-of-a-kind gifts that speak to their unique style and interests—because standard chocolates and flowers just won't cut it this Valentine's Day!

featured customer reviews

For another couple's wedding, baby birth, etc.

Perfect as a Valentine's gift for my husband commemorating our wedding date! Love the idea. Had to have first one replaced since it fell and broke since the little loops on the moon itself are really chintzy and came undone. But my husband loves it and we enjoy it each morning in our sunroom with our plants!

Sarah
Erie, PA

Romantic Night Stained Glass Moon

$75.00

I purchased three of these for Christmas gifts in December.

Gave three for gifts. Then regretted not getting one for myself. So around Valentine's Day I got one for my husband. It was a great addition to our Valentine's dinner at home since we couldn't go out. Have to find special ways to celebrate at home these days!

Tim
Pennsylvania

Gourmet Oil Dipping Spice Kit

$45.00

Birthday Month Wine Stoppers

This was a gift for my sister who had her birthday in February. As soon as her boyfriend saw it, he immediately ordered himself one.

Jill Zie
Boise, Idaho

Birthstone Wine Bottle Stopper

$28.00

Perfect Gift to Someone Special

I can't wait for my best friend to open this gift. She's someone who has everything, so this unique gift is perfect! Well constructed, written using a graceful font, with beautiful birthday month stones elegantly displayed.

Bestie
Kaneohe, Hawaii

Gems of Virtue Birthstone Art

~~~~Previous Price~~ $50.00~~ $24.99

Unique gift for music lovers

I ordered as a Valentine's Day gift for my boyfriend who is in the music industry, put the name of his mixtape on it and he LOVED! I think it's best used as a decorative piece as I wouldn't want it to get dirty.

Gyrlredd3
Atlanta, GA

Personalized Mixtape Doormat

$38.00

Item not in your wishlist
Turquoise Cat Studs$28.00
5 stars out of 5 7
Item not in your wishlist
Low StockFlecks of Gold Birthstone Necklace$50.00
2.5 stars out of 5 2
Item not in your wishlist
Low StockBirth Month Geode Art$165.00
not yet rated
Item not in your wishlist
Birthstone Balloon Earrings~~~~Previous Price~~ $58.00~~ New Price $28.99
not yet rated
Item not in your wishlist
Sliced Raw Diamond Birthstone Necklace~~~~Previous Price~~ $145.00~~ New Price $72.99
not yet rated
Item not in your wishlist
CustomizableRomantic Night Stained Glass Moon$75.00
4.4 stars out of 5 16
Item not in your wishlist
Gift SetOlive Oil Dipping Gift Set$68.00 - $98.00
4.8 stars out of 5 19
Item not in your wishlist
Gourmet Oil Dipping Spice Kit$45.00
4.8 stars out of 5 562
Item not in your wishlist
Birthstone Wine Bottle Stopper$28.00
4.9 stars out of 5 271
Item not in your wishlist
CustomizableCustom Mixed Birthstone Necklace$75.00
4.7 stars out of 5 42
Item not in your wishlist
Low StockNational Park Chocolate Bar Collection$28.00
5 stars out of 5 2
Item not in your wishlist
Jewel-Tone Birth Month Dish$25.00
4.9 stars out of 5 111
Item not in your wishlist
New!Sharks and Other Sea Monsters Deluxe Pop-Up$50.00
not yet rated
Item not in your wishlist
Shattered Glass Ceiling Necklace$68.00 - $80.00
4.8 stars out of 5 368
Item not in your wishlist
3-Minute Apple Baker$30.00
5 stars out of 5 9
Item not in your wishlist
Gems of Virtue Birthstone Art~~~~Previous Price~~ $50.00~~ New Price $24.99
5 stars out of 5 4
Item not in your wishlist
Booze-Infused Hot Sauce Trio$29.00
4.8 stars out of 5 36
Item not in your wishlist
New!Cast Iron Rocking Mortar & Pestle$75.00
not yet rated
Item not in your wishlist
CustomizablePersonalized Mixtape Doormat$38.00
4.4 stars out of 5 204
Item not in your wishlist
Low StockMilestone Anniversary Love Geode Art$115.00
5 stars out of 5 2
Item not in your wishlist
Limited-Time DealTogether Forever Infinity Art~~~~Previous Price~~ $98.00~~ New Price $28.99
3 stars out of 5 1

back

1 - 21 (of 21 items)

similar categories

valentine’s day gifts for him

gifts for girlfriends

gifts for couples

valentine’s day gifts for husbands

Looking to impress your crush this Valentine’s Day? You’re in the right place! Our collection of gifts is designed for those who make your heart race and your mind spin. Whether they’re a foodie, a book lover, or a crafty creator, these one-of-a-kind finds will show you’ve put thought into what they really love. Forget the generic chocolates and cliché roses; it’s time to go for something that truly resonates with their unique personality and interests.

When it comes to picking the perfect gift, think about what makes your crush tick. Is there a hobby that lights up their eyes? A quirky trait that always makes you smile? Zeroing in on their passions can lead you to a gift they didn’t even know they needed. And remember, personalization is key—customizable options add that extra touch that says, "I see you." For more inspiration, check out our full collection of Valentine's Day gifts that celebrate love in all its unique forms!