Uncommon Goods | 117 Engagement Gift Ideas for Creative Presents to Impress Your Loved Ones 2026

We're doubling our Better to Give donations through Dec. 31. Pick a non-profit at checkout and we'll donate $2 ($4 for Perks members) at no cost to you.

Engagement Gift Ideas for Creative Presents to Impress Your Loved Ones

Love is in the air and this collection of engagement gift ideas is here to celebrate the joyous occasion! From charming trinkets to heartfelt keepsakes, these gifts will make the happy couple say 'I do' to your thoughtfulness!

    featured customer reviews

    5 stars out of 5

    Perfect gift!

    I got this gift for my friend's wedding anniversary. It was perfect! My friend loved it as she and her husband are always overthinking ideas for dates. They love it!

    • Nat
    • Bronx, NY
    5 stars out of 5

    On Fire

    The personalized match box was a clever play on words for several couples on Valentine's Day. The matches themselves are great to have around for all your candle lovers.

    • Ever the Shopper
    • Houston, Texas
    5 stars out of 5

    wonderful idea for brides

    Perfect product for those who are engaged purchased on a whim for my daughter and she loved it. she had seen on tic Toc. I just saw on your sight very pleased with purchase!

    • posh shopper
    • Door County Wisconsin
    5 stars out of 5

    Fantastic gift for newly engaged or newlywed couples

    I purchased this customized gift for my 25 year old niece who recently got engaged. She adored it. Its got pockets for keeping love notes, cards, and keepsakes from their trips together. It is a high quality product that I would not hesitate to buy again. Perfect for both newly engaged and newly wed couples

    • Sue
    • New York
    5 stars out of 5

    Best Engagement Present

    I needed a unique engagement present for a couple in their 20's, so I immediately got onto Uncommon Goods, knowing I could find a gift that no one else would get for the couple. I loved that I could choose which types of glasses I wanted, and be able to get their initials etched into the glass. Such a great item!

    • TJ
    • Stratford, CT
    5 stars out of 5

    Perfect Engagement Gift

    This was a great find in honor of our recent engagement. We will be happy to have it displayed at our wedding also. #sweepstakes

    • Danny Boy
    • St Petersburg, FL
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizableA Year of Dates – 52 Surprise Envelopes$42.00 - $52.00
    4.9 stars out of 5 9
  • Item not in your wishlist
    Wedding Keepsake Library$115.00
    4.9 stars out of 5 30
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizablePersonalized Jewelry Tray$40.00
    5 stars out of 5 4
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizablePersonalized Ring Tray$38.00
    4 stars out of 5 2
  • Item not in your wishlist
    CustomizablePersonalized Wedding Keepsake Library$145.00
    4.8 stars out of 5 5