Uncommon Goods | Peanut Butter Sampler | Gourmet Peanut Butter

We're doubling our Better to Give donations through Dec. 31. Pick a non-profit at checkout and we'll donate $2 ($4 for Perks members) at no cost to you.

Item not in your wishlist
Peanut Butter Sampler
Peanut Butter Sampler
more info customer photos

Peanut butter sampler pack? Don’t mind if I do uncommongoods

Peanut Butter Sampler thumbnail 1Peanut Butter Sampler thumbnail 2
more info customer photos

Peanut butter sampler pack? Don’t mind if I do uncommongoods

Peanut Butter Sampler

Created by Kathy Weed

Made from honey roasted peanuts, this small-batch peanut butter sampler includes six yummy blends.

$45.00

great gift delicious flavors unique variety fun experience peanut butter lover tasty treat easy to enjoy

Uncommon Perks

Shipping to change

backordered
Arrives ... Order within   00:00:00
Learn more

Arrival estimate is based on Standard shipping to the zip code provided. Other ship methods with different arrival dates are available in checkout.

Free forever returnsdetails

If your gift will arrive late, let them know it's on the way – and worth the wait.

Handmade

Independent Maker

Made in USA

What Makes It Uncommon

If you've ever caught yourself thinking, "Wow, peanut butter just couldn't get any better," while liberally spreading it over some perfectly warmed bread, you're dead wrong, my friend. Add chocolate chips, pretzels, toffee, cherries, white chocolate, and more to the mix and you've got the type of peanut butter that's the stuff of kids'—and adults'—delicious dreams. Spread on fresh bread, dip with apples, or just enjoy with a spoon—we'll be doing the same.

  • Made from honey roasted peanuts, this crunchy, small batch assortment is chock full of sweet and salty additions.
  • Set of six different flavors; 6 oz. each.
  • See nutritional information here.
  • Handmade by Kathy Weed in Zionsville, Indiana.

created by

Kathy Weed

“I love to envision people eating a jar with a spoon, and thinking that they are in their happy place.”

Many culinary empires begin with a recipe. Kathy Weed’s began with a lesson—her artisanal peanut butter was a way to teach her children about running a small business. The endeavor, which she jokingly terms "a lemonade stand on steroids," has since expanded well beyond the weekend farmer’s market.

Usually ships within 24 hours.

See all shipping options and costs

This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S. See International FAQ for more info.

Uncommon Perks

Get unlimited FAST, FREE SHIPPING (and other good stuff) with a 14-day free trial of Perks.

join uncommon perks

Sadly, we are unable to ship to APO, FPO, or DPO addresses at this time. We are working towards a solution that will allow us to resume this type of shipping.

Need to return? Free returns are accepted forever—no time limits. Within 30 days of delivery, refunds to the original payment method will be available. After 30 days, refunds will be processed to a digital gift card. See our return policy for more details.

Measurements

Set of 6
2.75" Dia x 2.5" H; 6 fl. oz. capacity

Care

Refrigeration not required.

Item ID

26444

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Customers also bought

Try our gift finder

similar categories
great gift delicious flavors unique variety fun experience peanut butter lover tasty treat easy to enjoy

People love this product for its delicious flavors and unique variety, making it a perfect gift for peanut butter lovers.

AI generated summary

  • 5 stars out of 5

    This was a great stocking stuffer - I split the different peanut butte…

    • Jaime
    • Undisclosed

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    It is delicious. Spread on toast and in a protien mix as a nut butter.…

    • Floppy the turtle
    • Eastern MT

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    Yes, you can go the traditional route and slather it on some bread, bu…

    • Christo
    • Sandy, Utah

    read full review

4.72
4.72 stars out of 5
based on 466 reviews
95%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
398 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
38 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
10 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
7 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
13 users rating this 1 star
  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Jaime
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • Undisclosed
  • Submitted as an incentivized review

Great stocking stuffer

This was a great stocking stuffer - I split the different peanut butters between family members, paired with the peanut butter spoon. I was told by those who received the peanut butters that these were quite tasty.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Floppy the turtle
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • Eastern MT
  • Submitted as an incentivized review

A delicous way to sample flavors.

It is delicious. Spread on toast and in a protien mix as a nut butter. The 6.5 oz size is equivalent to 3/4 Cup and that is the amount needed. A healthy snack when you need a boost of energy. I plan on ordering more and telling friends and family about who you are.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Christo
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • Sandy, Utah
  • Submitted as an incentivized review

George Washington Carver would be proud!

Yes, you can go the traditional route and slather it on some bread, but the options are endless: pancakes, waffles, cut fruit, in smoothies, cookies, etc. (you catch my spread?).

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • lenorrom
  • verified reviewer
  • LIC NY

love nuts!

I bought this peanut butter sampler for my husband, peanut butter aficionado. In all the 16 years I know him, he has never asked for anything. At al. Except this What flavor did you like best ? (I asked) "donno- all of them!"

  • 4 stars out of 5
  • Al
  • verified reviewer
  • Fairfax, Va

Delicious snack packed w protein and lots o flavor options!

Bought this selection of small-jarred, artisnal peanut butters for myself, but had so many that I decided to gift a few to friends and family. Since they are all natural, had to give them a good stir to mix in separated oil, but worth it to get all of the delicious add ins in each bite. As someone who likes to try lots of different flavors, I loved that the quantities were small enough that I could get through each jar while still fresh AND have plenty more to sample. Wonderful to support a small, family owned business and well worth the price. Another gem that Uncommon Goods has introduced me to!

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Erin T.
  • verified reviewer
  • Ohio

Mind blown!

These were all so delicious. We had so much fun as a family tasting each one and deciding our favorites. The fan favorites were the white chocolate and toffee crunch flavors. Everyone is enjoying them in different ways. My husband loves it on ice cream, the kids love it or a biscoff cookie and my favorite is on some toast with fruit. This set makes a great gift or stocking stuffer. Can't wait to reorder.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Nana Jo
  • verified reviewer
  • Pennsylvania

So Yummy

The taste combinations are crazy good. Each jar could be eaten with a spoon. So I did! This was my second batch and a treat just for me. Quality product.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • VAA
  • verified reviewer
  • Boulder Creek, CA

This peanut butter is so good!

We love all the different combos of peanut butter

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • PK
  • verified reviewer
  • NE

Peanut Butter Treats!

Love the unique flavors! Excellent tasty treat!

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Babette
  • verified reviewer
  • Los Angeles

Great gift for the PB lover!

He loved it! He enjoyed trying out all the different variety of peanut butter.

customer photos

Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.

photos from reviews

  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Peanut Butter Sampler from Uncommon Goods. Customer submitted image.
  • Port Charlotte, Florida

Is there soy lecithin or sunflower lecithin or any type of lecithin in these PB butters?

Verified reply from Maxienne

The assortment contains soy lecithin.

  • Minnesota

Are all of the peanut butters gluten free?

Verified reply from Itamar

Great question! All of the flavors are gluten free except Dream Big, which has pretzels (made of wheat flour) in it, and Go Lucky, which has Rice Krispies (which contain barley malt, which contains some gluten) in it.

  • NYC, NY

Can you please tel me grams of sugar in the product? Or share a nutrition label or two? I have PB lover that I want to sent these to but too much added sugar might not work. Thank you!

Verified reply from Melise

Hello! These contain between 6 and 10 grams of sugar per 2 tbs, with a total of 9-13 grams of carbohydrates.

  • FL

What size is a serving and how many carbs/serving?

Verified reply from Allison

A serving size is 2 tablespoons with 180 calories per serving. Carbohydrate total is between 10 and 13 grams.

  • ny, ny

What is the size of the jars/quantity in each?

Verified reply from Megan

Each jar is 6oz and you will receive a set of 6 flavors. Please visit the product page to see the flavors in the set.

  • Utah

Is the peanut butter smooth? or does it have the chunks?

Verified reply from Valerie

All of the flavors have a texture due to the extra ingredients, and some are chunkier than others. None are totally smooth.

  • undisclosed

Are the jars glass or plastic?

Verified reply from Michelle

The jars are plastic.

Are they certified Kosher?

Verified reply from Valerie

This product is not certified Kosher.

  • United States

Do any of the ingredients include corn syrup, high fructose corn syrup, and/or hydrogenated oils?

Verified reply from Martin

They do not. These are made with sugar and natural peanut oil.

Similar items

If your Valentine has a serious thing for peanut butter, our gifting team knows this sampler will hit the spot. Explore our full collection of Valentine's Day gifts for more delicious ways to show you care.

From foodies to snack enthusiasts, our gifting team has organized something for everyone. Browse creative gifts for him and unique gifts for her that celebrate their passions.