Peanut Butter Sampler

Made from honey roasted peanuts, this small-batch peanut butter sampler includes six yummy blends.
created by

Jon Weed

$40.00

created by

Jon Weed

read more about the maker

So Long, Jelly

If you've ever caught yourself thinking "wow, peanut butter just couldn't get any better" while liberally spreading it over some perfectly warmed bread, you're dead wrong, my friend. Add chocolate chips, pretzels, toffee, popcorn, white chocolate, and more to the mix and you've got the type of peanut butter kid and adult dreams were made of. Made from honey roasted peanuts, this small batch assortment offers a crunchy/smooth texture hybrid that's chock full of sweet and salty additions. Spread on fresh bread, dip with apples, or just enjoy with a spoon—we'll be doing the same. Handmade by Jon Weed in Zionsville, Indiana.

Visit the Blog to see some of our favorite recipes featuring the Peanut Butter Sampler!

US_IN

Made in Indiana

“I love to envision people sitting on their couch, watching their favorite TV show, eating a jar of [our] peanut butter with a spoon and thinking they are in their happy place.”

Many culinary empires begin with a recipe. Jon Weed’s began with a lesson–his artisanal peanut butter company was born in an effort to teach his children about running a small business. The endeavor, which he jokingly terms “a lemonade stand on steroids,” has turned into an education for the entire family as the brand has expanded to retailers well beyond the weekend farmer’s market the Weeds originally targeted. What sets the product apart: ingredients from popcorn to pretzels to raisins that make the concoctions good enough to eat straight out of the jar.

“I love to envision that there are people sitting on their couch, watching their favorite TV show, eating a jar of [our peanut butter] with a spoon and thinking that they are in their happy place,” Jon says.

Handmade Made in the USA
Measurements
2.75" Dia x 2.5" H; 6 fl. oz. capacity
Care
Refrigeration not required.
Notes
Sampler Includes:
Happy Trails Mix: Flaxseed, chocolate chips, raisins, split peanuts
White Chocolate Pretzel: Pretzel pieces, white chocolate chips
Snickerdoodle: Snickerdoodle popcorn
Chocolate Toffee: Milk chocolate, bits of toffee, rice crispies
Keep Smunchy: Honey roasted peanuts
Chocolate Coconut: Dark chocolate, shredded coconut, almonds
Item ID
26444

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Most of our items are in stock and will ship quickly. Orders for in-stock items placed before 5pm ET Monday through Friday, excluding Federal holidays, will ship:
Economy shipping:
within 8 days, arriving no later than the 9th business day after the order was placed.
Standard shipping:
within 4 days, arriving 5 business days after the order was placed.
Preferred shipping:
within 2 days, arriving 3 business days after the order was placed.
Expedited shipping:
within 1 day, arriving 2 business days after the order was placed.
Express shipping:
will ship the same day and arrive 1 business day later.

Please note: This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S.

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
UncommonGoodsPeanut Butter Sampler
 
4.7

(based on 84 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (69)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (12)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (0)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (0)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (3)

96%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Pros

  • Flavorful (25)
  • Well packaged (23)
  • Good value (11)
  • Easy to prepare (8)
  • Non-perishable (7)

Cons

No Cons

Best Uses

  • Snack (25)
  • Gift (24)
  • Anytime (21)
  • Holidays (9)
  • Add flavor (6)
    • Reviewer Profile:
    • Foodie (13), Health conscious (12), Simple tastes (12), Frequent diner (6)
    • Was this a gift?:
    • Yes (78), No (8)

Most Liked Positive Review

 

was a big hit

I purchased this gift twice, once for my sister and once for my nephew. I spoke with my niece after Christmas, and she said my nephew and their daughter were just eating it...Read complete review

I purchased this gift twice, once for my sister and once for my nephew. I spoke with my niece after Christmas, and she said my nephew and their daughter were just eating it out of the jar with a spoon. They all said they loved the taste. My sister said it is a bit thick to spread on bread, but she enjoyed just eating it as well. Maybe it would go better with a thick bagel or some very hearty bread? I loved the idea that this is a family business that the mom and dad do with their kids to teach them about business!

VS

Most Liked Negative Review

 

Peanut oil leaked everywhere.

When this package arrived it was bathed in peanut oil. Non of the lids of the jars were tight. They leaked all over inside the box and seeped out of the box.

When this package arrived it was bathed in peanut oil. Non of the lids of the jars were tight. They leaked all over inside the box and seeped out of the box.

Reviewed by 84 customers

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »

 
4.0

Calling all peanut butter lovers

By 

from Kirkland WA

Verified Buyer

Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

Have not opened yet but I know he will love this. Cute packaging and good variety of fun flavors. Arrived quickly and in great condition.

  • Was this a gift?:
  • Yes
 
4.0

Looks good

By 

from Indianapolis, IN

Verified Buyer

Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

We have yet to try these items, as they will be a Christmas gift for my parents but the packaging looks great and the descriptions sound yummy.

  • Was this a gift?:
  • Yes
 
5.0

best gift for PB lovers

By 

from Binghamton, NY

Verified Buyer

Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

One of my friends is crazy about peanut butter and I gave this to her for her birthday. She will not stop raving about it! She finished some jars almost immediately and tells all her friends and family to buy it for her next birthday. Definitely a great gift idea!

  • Was this a gift?:
  • Yes
 
5.0

A delicious idea!

By 

from Chicago

Verified Buyer

Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

My Dad has been a peanut butter lover his whole life. As far back as I can remember he would come home from work and have a big spoonful. When I saw this on the Uncommon Goods website I knew it was just the thing for his birthday. He loved it!

  • Was this a gift?:
  • Yes
 
5.0

Great gift for a peanut butter lover

By 

from Fort Wayne IN

Verified Buyer

Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

Fun way to get your peanut butter fix on crackers or a spoon! Interesting combo paired with the beer jelly.

  • Was this a gift?:
  • Yes
 
5.0

Peanut Butter Sampler

By 

from Okatie, SC

Verified Buyer

Pros

    Cons

      Best Uses

      • When you feel the need for something sweet.

      Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

      I love this peanut butter so much that I sometimes just eat it with a spoon! It is soooo delicious.

      • Was this a gift?:
      • Yes
       
      5.0

      Repeat Buyer!

      By 

      from Chicago, IL

      Verified Reviewer

      Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

      I bought this as a stocking stuffer for my peanut-butter-loving boyfriend last Christmas and have bought it again for his birthday and just because. He talks about it non-stop and is totally obsessed. I've gotten him a lot of gifts but this was by far the best one! Definitely recommend for anyone who likes peanut butter!

      • Was this a gift?:
      • Yes
       
      4.0

      Fun and unexpected

      By 

      from Tennessee

      Verified Buyer

      Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

      So far each variety of peanut butter is good and the gift recipient is satisfied.

      • Was this a gift?:
      • Yes
       
      4.0

      Great Flavors to eat all by themselves.

      By 

      from Yucaipa, CA

      Verified Buyer

      Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

      They taste really good and would get 5 stars if the price was a little more reasonable. Nice variety with unusual flavors that are so good you do not want to put them on a cracker but eat them straight. I keep them in the fridge so they last longer and stay fresh.

      • Was this a gift?:
      • Yes

      (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

       
      5.0

      Better than expected

      By 

      from Andover, CT

      Verified Buyer

      Comments about UncommonGoods Peanut Butter Sampler:

      I bought this as a gift for my girlfriend who absolutely loves peanut butter and eats it with a spoon more often than actually spreading it on bread. She was extremely happy with this gift and although she was skeptical of some of the flavors she ended up loving them all. Will definitely buy again!

      • Was this a gift?:
      • Yes

      Displaying reviews 1-10

      Back to top

      Previous | Next »

      Related Products
      Hive Mentality. When Zeke Freeman—a gastronomist who trained ...
      Description:
      Hive Mentality. When Zeke Freeman—a gastronomist who trained under famed chef Alain Ducasse and helped curate the gourmet offerings at Dean & Deluca—got into the honey business, he wasn't looking to produce a garden-variety sweetener. Instead, his approach resembles that ...
      Mountain Preserves. Transform your morning toast and add ...
      Description:
      Mountain Preserves. Transform your morning toast and add an uncommon dimension to recipes with this artisanal jelly & jam set. When Walter and Nancy Warner moved to Vermont they were inspired by the bountiful local food and beer culture, started ...
      Fire in the Belly. Valerie Roth’s food experiments ...
      Description:
      Fire in the Belly. Valerie Roth’s food experiments began with concocting sweet potato chips as a seven-year-old in her family's New Jersey kitchen. Today, this culinary alchemist works with raw, organic apple cider vinegar and nutrient-dense botanicals to formulate a ...
      Chili con Crunch. Fair warning: this is not ...
      Description:
      Chili con Crunch. Fair warning: this is not your granny's granola. Each bite is a flavor-bomb combo of garlicky, sweet, spicy, and umami—the sought-after, savory fifth flavor. Mix up your regular yogurt-and-granola routine, or try it on tacos, avocado toast, ...
      Sugar Coat It. Inspired by the Mexican confection ...
      Description:
      Sugar Coat It. Inspired by the Mexican confection cajeta, Steve Reid and Judith Irving create their silky sweet, small-batch caramel sauce with a hometown twist. Using local Vermont goat's milk, they hand-stir each sampler until it reaches its peak velvety ...