Uncommon Goods | Whiskey Toffee Gift Set | whiskey toffee

We're doubling our Better to Give donations through Dec. 31. Pick a non-profit at checkout and we'll donate $2 ($4 for Perks members) at no cost to you.

Item not in your wishlist

Whiskey Toffee Gift Set

Created by Sarah Coulman

A rich, buttery toffee trio infused with premium spirits and handcrafted to perfection.

$45.00

Uncommon Perks

Shipping to change

Arrives ... Order within   00:00:00
Learn more

Arrival estimate is based on Standard shipping to the zip code provided. Other ship methods with different arrival dates are available in checkout.

Free forever returnsdetails

Handmade

Independent Maker

Made in USA

What Makes It Uncommon

As an expert candymaker, Sarah Coulman knows that spirits and sweets are naturally luscious together. Her handcrafted toffee trio takes the buttery confection to new heights with infusions of real bourbon, rye whiskey, and brandy…but she doesn't stop there. These small-batch flavors are made with extra butter and feature a two-sided coating of chocolate, creating a decadent delight for anyone who loves rich flavors with a spirited twist.

  • Gift set includes 3 varieties:
      • Bourbon Toffee: Almonds, milk chocolate, and bourbon
      • Toffee in the Rye: Milk chocolate and rye whiskey
      • Brandy Old Fashioned Toffee: Pecans, milk chocolate, brandy, and old fashioned cocktail mixer
  • Crafted with more butter than sugar for a signature crunch that's satisfying, not brittle.
  • Family-owned business dedicated to quality local ingredients and traditional techniques.
  • Three 8-oz. bags.
  • See nutritional information here.
  • Handmade in Wisconsin.

created by

Sarah Coulman

Sarah Coulman started making toffee 25 years ago when she and her husband, Bill, wanted a special treat for family gatherings. Years later, they turned it into a business so they could balance work with raising their five kids. Today, home and work base is the same farm in East Troy, Wisconsin, where Sarah grew up—and their toffee has won international awards. "I didn't see myself wanting to run our own business," Sarah says of their sweet journey together. "But here we are, loving it!"

This item ships directly from the maker. If you order today your item will ship no later than 1/8/2026.

Items that are made to order or oversized can't be sent in a Gift Bag. Instead, you can include your Gift Message on the shipment's packing slip.  At this time, this item cannot be shipped to APO/FPO addresses, P.O. Boxes, or to U.S. Territories including Minor Outlyling Islands. Contact custom@uncommongoods.com with any questions.

This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S. See International FAQ for more info.

Uncommon Perks

Get unlimited FAST, FREE SHIPPING (and other good stuff) with a 14-day free trial of Perks.

join uncommon perks

Need to return? Free returns are accepted forever—no time limits. Within 30 days of delivery, refunds to the original payment method will be available. After 30 days, refunds will be processed to a digital gift card. See our return policy for more details.

Measurements

8 oz. per bag

Care

5 Month Shelf Life.

Ingredients

Whiskey Toffee Gift Set

Toffee in the Rye
SUGAR, COCOA BUTTER, MILK, CHOCOLATE LIQUOR, NONFAT MILK, SOY LECITHIN, VANILLA, SUGAR, BUTTER (CREAM, SALT), ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE, DISTILLED, WHISKEY, 86 PROOF, LIGHT CORN SYRUP (CORN SYRUP, SALT, VANILLA)

Bourbon Toffee
SUGAR, COCOA BUTTER, MILK, CHOCOLATE LIQUOR, NONFAT MILK, SOY LECITHIN, VANILLA, SUGAR, BUTTER (CREAM, SALT), ALMONDS, BOURBON WHISKY, LIGHT CORN SYRUP (CORN SYRUP, SALT, VANILLA)

Brandy Old Fashioned Toffee
SUGAR, COCOA BUTTER, MILK, CHOCOLATE LIQUOR, NONFAT MILK, SOY LECITHIN, VANILLA, SUGAR, BUTTER (CREAM, SALT), ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE, DISTILLED, WHISKEY, 86 PROOF, LIGHT CORN SYRUP (CORN SYRUP, SALT, VANILLA)

Contains Milk, Almond, Soy

Item ID

61306

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Customers also bought

Try our gift finder

similar categories

Similar items

Nothing says "I love you" quite like handcrafted sweets with a spirited twist—and our gifting team selected this toffee trio for those who appreciate the finer things. Treat your Valentine to something truly special from our complete collection of unique Valentine's Day gifts that go beyond the expected.

Whether you're shopping for a whiskey enthusiast or someone with a sweet tooth, our gifting team has curated options that hit the mark. Browse thoughtful gifts for him and memorable gifts for her that celebrate their one-of-a-kind taste.