Uncommon Goods | 83 Gift Ideas for Mystery Lovers - Puzzling and Literary Items 2026

Gifts for Mystery Lovers - Puzzling and Literary Items

Unravel the excitement with this collection of gifts for mystery lovers! From secret message pens to detective-themed puzzles, this assortment is sure to keep them on their toes. Perfect for those who love a good whodunit and a dash of intrigue!

    featured customer reviews

    5 stars out of 5

    Creative, unique, and fun

    My friend loves puzzles and murder mystery games, so this gift was perfect for her. She especially loved the cool art throughout the book.

    • Jay
    • Colorado
    5 stars out of 5

    Excellent gift

    Very impressed. The cover is sturdy, well made and has nice vibrate colors. The story is woven throughout the multitude of puzzles in the book. A must for any Agatha Christie fan. The recipient was pleasantly surprised and I scored that as a win.

    • Birdie
    • Undisclosed
    5 stars out of 5

    Perfect Gift For My Science Lover

    My adult brother is very into science and researches everything. Every item in this box every month gives him something super interesting to read about. It comes with info cards for everything but he likes to look up ever item and spend hours really diving down each rabbit hole. He loves collecting all the scientific odds & ends in the box so he looks forward to receiving it every month.

    • Anna the Science Hero
    • San Diego
    5 stars out of 5

    So much fun for book lovers

    If you love reading and discovering new books, this is a perfect purchase. The surprise of what's inside is like opening a gift.

    • Amanda
    • Washington, DC
    5 stars out of 5

    Great gift for amateur sleuths

    I purchased this for a relative who loves to watch true crime, listen to podcasts, and solve mysteries. This gives him enjoy solving mysteries in a new way!

    • Amateur Sleuth
    • Noblesville, IN
    5 stars out of 5

    Love!! Perfect gift for a mystery-lover

    Got this as a birthday gift for my mom- who loves puzzles and mystery books/shows - so it was the perfect combo. She LOVED it. It took her some time to do, and was so well made and a fun storyline. The quality was great as well! Highly recommend #sweepstakes

    • Krista-belle
    • Undisclosed
  • Item not in your wishlist
    Low StockMurder Mystery Puzzle Book$19.00
    4.7 stars out of 5 127
  • Item not in your wishlist
    A Blind Date with A Book$19.00
    3.7 stars out of 5 9