Goat's Milk Caramel Sampler

Steve Reid and Judith Irving use local Vermont goat's milk to create these rich caramel sauces.

$25.00 $ 14.99

created by

Steve Reid and Judith Irving

read more about the maker

Sugar Coat It

Inspired by the Mexican confection cajeta, Steve Reid and Judith Irving create their silky sweet, small-batch caramel sauce with a hometown twist. Using local Vermont goat's milk, they hand-stir each sampler until it reaches its peak velvety texture, then it's sealed and sent to you. Whether you top ice cream, dip pretzels, or go straight for a spoonful, the flavor is unlike anything you can find at the corner store. Sampler flavors include: Original Caramel, Cold Brew Coffee, Salted Bourbon, and Vanilla Bean. Handmade in Vermont.

Please note: the Cold Brew Coffee caramel sauce is not available at this time and has been replaced in the sampler with Cinnamon caramel sauce.


Made in Vermont

Husband and wife team, Steve Reid and Judith Irving has a farm that you'll find down a beautiful dirt road carving through the hills of Central Vermont where they (along with their team of 4) have perfected the art of caramel making.

Read a Q&A with Steve and Judith.

Handmade Made in the USA
Box: 5" L x 5" W x 3" H; Four 2 fl oz jars of caramel
Refrigerate caramel after opening. Expires 4 months after opening.
Ingredients by Flavor:

Original: goat's milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda
Salted Bourbon: goat's milk, pure cane sugar, Kentucky straight Bourbon, baking soda, sea salt
Cold Brew Coffee: goat's milk, pure cane sugar, Vermont Artisan Coffee Cold Brew, baking soda
Vanilla Bean: goat's milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda, French Bourbon vanilla beans
Item ID

Still haven't found the details you're looking for? Check out our Product Q&A!

Most of our items are in stock and will ship quickly. Orders for in-stock items placed before 5pm ET Monday through Friday, excluding Federal holidays, will ship in the US:
Economy shipping:
within 8 days, arriving no later than the 9th business day after the order was placed.
Standard shipping:
within 4 days, arriving 5 business days after the order was placed.
Preferred shipping:
within 2 days, arriving 3 business days after the order was placed.
Expedited shipping:
within 1 day, arriving 2 business days after the order was placed.
Express shipping:
will ship the same day and arrive 1 business day later.

Please note: This item is not available to ship outside of the U.S.

Delicious so many ways


I have had many varieties of this caramel. All wonderful. On Ice cream, pancakes and by the spoonful. It would be delicious on/in brownies. I was an exchange student in Mexico many, many years ago and this reminds me of cajeta.



Yummy Non-Cow Dairy Caramel


Thanks for making a delicious dairy sweet for those of sensitive to cow dairy.



New favorite in our house!


You can literally put this stuff on everything!

Seattle, WA


The Best Caramel


We use this in our coffee and cappuccino, as well as on fruit and ice cream!



Goat's Milk Caramel Sampler

5.0 4