SEED POT MAKER

Cassie, UncommonGoods Community Moderator

We're always excited about cool new garden gadgets, so we were thrilled when Josh found this Seed Pot Maker! Would you love to get planting with this handy tool?

Christina
Vote: Thumbs down!

cool idea but i wouldn't use it and i don't know anyone who'd want it as a gift.

Liane
Vote: Thumbs up!

I like this, I'd definitely use it. It'd make a great gift for some gardening friends.

Mary
Vote: Thumbs up!

probably won't be a big seller, but still might prove to be "just the thing" for people trying to find the perfect gift for a green thumb. definitely something worth carrying in the store.

Seneca
Vote: Thumbs up!

Great gift for those with a green thumb.

JoBeth
Vote: Thumbs up!

I think this would be a great gift for young gardeners.

Erin
Vote: Thumbs down!

just seems needless to have something to shape paper.

Jenny
Vote: Thumbs down!

a paper shaper?

Joanne
Vote: Thumbs up!

The acorn-shaped top is too cute. I work at a park and we have used pot makers similar to these in our nature programs. I want one for myself!

Julie
Vote: Thumbs down!

It seems really complicated to use, and the wooden stand is not even used in the final process.

Amy
Vote: Thumbs up!

we garden, we start our own seeds...i love the concept would most definatly buy one!!

Robin
Vote: Thumbs up!

I find this a wonderful tool for growing your own herbs and seedlings without waste!!!

Carolyn
Vote: Thumbs down!

It looks a little..."suggestive" as well.

christie
Vote: Thumbs down!

visually unappealing

ERIN
Vote: Thumbs down!

Cute idea - but I'm not an avid gardener and don't start my own seedlings

Lauren
Vote: Thumbs down!

Am I the only one who thought this looks sort of...phallic?

lisa
Vote: Thumbs up!

LOVE anything that turns trash into usable goods!

Laura

The most phallic item in your catalog.

Kristi

I want to giggle like a dirty-minded teenager when I look at this thing. Ok, so I did actually giggle. I mean seriously I could see a guy saying something about his "Mighty Oak".

Christine
Vote: Thumbs down!

If made in the US, I'd buy it!

Jessica Kate
Vote: Thumbs up!

Still not sure exactly how this works, but I still think it is cool.

Jen
Vote: Thumbs down!

The pot looks like it would fall apart the first time you watered the seedling. Nice in theory, but I don't see it working.

Elisa

Great idea to not only recycle but to also plant, plant, plant!

Pamela
Vote: Thumbs up!

I think its a unique concept. I like what it says as well.

Sue Eveleth
Vote: Thumbs down!

It's made in China. :(

p
Vote: Thumbs down!

It seems unnecessary and the shape is phallic

Sharon

This looks mighty suggestive, and pointless for its purpose. Just get a toiletpaper or paper towel roll and use that. Then recycle it when you're done.

Heidi
Vote: Thumbs down!

i thought this was cute until i realized how phallic it looks. really cute idea though maybe flip the acorn if you could figure out a way

Jennifer
Vote: Thumbs up!

This would be the PERFECT teacher gift at my kids' school. That is their slogan and acorns and oak trees feature prominently as decor and on the grounds. Please carry it!

Darcy
Vote: Thumbs down!

In concept I love this product. What I don't like is that it is made in China and costs $17. We can be pretty sure that someone is making an enormous profit off these items as things are notoriously cheap to manufacture in China as they "employ" basically slave labor and don't have environmental and other important manufacturing regulations. Something this simple need not cost $ 17 or should we support Chinese manufacturing.

Letty
Vote: Thumbs down!

I can buy a lot of peat pots for 17.....besides, it looks obscene!

stacy

I like the item! However, wish it was made in America.

Rebecca
Vote: Thumbs up!

Stocking stuffer for my garden obsessed 4 1/2 year old!

Melissa
Vote: Thumbs down!

I like the concept, but that acorn on top looks a little too suggestive...not something I'd have out in the open!

Jenny
Vote: Thumbs down!

Does it come in different sizes and in a darker stain?

Jess
Vote: Thumbs down!

Maybe if the acorn was flipped...looks...um, well, you know...

annie

I think this is an awesome product however I personall y prefer to purchase items made in America since our economy is worse than China's.

Kay
Vote: Thumbs down!

What a waste of $17.

Kelly
Vote: Thumbs up!

I've been gardening for 20 years and have always wanted one but never bought one for myself. I'd love to get it as a gift!

Jenni
Vote: Thumbs down!

In this economic climate is this really what people would spend their money on...really? More over, it is made in CHINA. Just say no to anything made in China!

Dawn
Vote: Thumbs down!

Too much trouble for a seed!

Chrissy
Vote: Thumbs up!

I know a few people who could use this. However, I wish it were made in America!

Janelle
Vote: Thumbs down!

looks too phallic.

JT
Vote: Thumbs down!

It looks phallic.

Mathew

What a great twist on a really great product. Wild and wolf always seem to go the extra mile too add something more to their products. I want one defo!

deborah
Vote: Thumbs up!

It's "a little corny..." but I have never seen anything similar

cliff
Vote: Thumbs up!

great item - eco friendly, never seen one like this before

genna
Vote: Thumbs up!

great little idea to make the most of your old newspapers!

Cassie, UncommonGoods Community Moderator

Thanks for all of the great feedback on this fun garden gadget! To see how to use the Seed Pot Maker click on the instructions thumbnail under the main image. Could this product help you get your garden growing?

Kate
Vote: Thumbs down!

Could do this on my own without this extra gadget.

emily
Vote: Thumbs up!

cute... but a little phallic (alot maybe??)

Erin
Vote: Thumbs up!

I would LOVE this! The tiny peat pots are seasonal in my area and aren't available year round. Heck, this might even make me start buying newspapers again!

virginia
Vote: Thumbs down!

it's um. a little well. i do not like to look at it.

Rebecca
Vote: Thumbs down!

Seriously? And,again, made in China.

Erin
Vote: Thumbs down!

Doesn't seem useful.

Whitney
Vote: Thumbs up!

I can think of a few people that would get a kick out of this and the price is guilt free.

Jennifer
Vote: Thumbs down!

Can be market as "Wooden Willy Paper Shaper."

Moddy
Vote: Thumbs down!

This is a reasonable price and all, but I just don't see why you'd need a thing like this at all. This would be like buying a tool to perfectly shape the ends of your rolled coin rolls - what's the point?

Geri
Vote: Thumbs up!

cute idea

Sofia
Vote: Thumbs up!

Good idea for someone who likes to start seedlings inside, to transplant out in thegarden!!!

kathy
Vote: Thumbs down!

To much of a novelty that would not be used. Clutter!

Patty
Vote: Thumbs down!

nice saying, but ugly product

Joanna
Vote: Thumbs up!

I've been looking for one of these for some time now. They are harder to find than you might think!

Meghan
Vote: Thumbs up!

gardening friends would love this!