Uncommon Goods | Christmas Gift for Husband: MLB Game-Used Baseball Beanie

Cyber Monday: Get FREE personalization on select items to make your gift extra uncommon. SHOP NOW

This item is no longer available

MLB Game-Used Baseball Beanie: Choose Your Team

MLB Game-Used Baseball Beanie: Choose Your Team

Created by Ward Wallau

Shop bestsellers

The superheroes of our collection: they save the day, every time.

Unique gift Warmth Conversation piece Quality construction Authenticity tag Collectible item

People love this product for its unique design, warmth, and quality construction, making it a perfect collectible gift for baseball fans.

AI generated summary

  • 5 stars out of 5

    This was the perfect gift for my friend's birthday. She lives in a col…

    • Daria the warrior
    • Washington, D.C.

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    My son wears it all the time and always tells the backstory of where i…

    • Mac
    • NJ

    read full review

  • 5 stars out of 5

    My friend I bought this hat for, has his own baseball gym and it's abo…

    • Rozyczka49
    • Methuen MA

    read full review

4.8
4.8 stars out of 5
based on 15 reviews
93%
of respondents would
recommend this to a friend
5 stars
14 users rating this 5 stars
4 stars
0 users rating this 4 stars
3 stars
0 users rating this 3 stars
2 stars
1 users rating this 2 stars
1 star
0 users rating this 1 star
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • Maddy
  • Detroit, MI

Not worth the money

I ordered a Detroit Tigers hat, MLB authentication website says the ball was used in a Washington/Milwaukee game. The bottom hem was already unraveling when I opened the box. Very disappointing, huge waste of money.

Response from merchant

Thank you for your feedback, and I’m truly sorry to hear about your experience. Based on our regular quality checks and positive feedback, this seems to be an unusual case, and we’d like to make it right. We’ll be reaching out directly to help resolve the issue. We appreciate you bringing it to our attention.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Daria the warrior
  • verified reviewer
  • Washington, D.C.

Perfect gift for baseball fans

This was the perfect gift for my friend's birthday. She lives in a colder climate so bonus she can stay warm with something that is unique, cute and pays homage to her favorite sport.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Mac
  • verified reviewer
  • NJ

It was worth the price

My son wears it all the time and always tells the backstory of where it came from.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Rozyczka49
  • verified reviewer
  • Methuen MA

I AM IN LOVE TWITH THIS GIFT

My friend I bought this hat for, has his own baseball gym and it's about to get displayed in a frame on the wall for everyone to see what happens with some of the baseballs.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Christine
  • New York, New York

I would buy this product again. Awesome gift idea!

I bought this hat as a gift and I not want to purchase one for myself too. It was well made, is pretty comfortable and warm, and it goes with everything. If you are looking for a unique gift for sports loving fans, I highly recommend this hat.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Sue the shopper
  • verified reviewer
  • Colorado

Gift

The beanie will provide warmth when my son is out in the elements. Will enjoy explaining the history of the cap's yarn.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Dawgy Dawg
  • Billings, MY

Amazing!!

Great for everyday use or to wear for game day! Great conversation piece!

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • Court
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • Madison, Al

I loved this product!

Loved this! Very unique.

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • LadyBanker
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • Virginia Beach. Virginia

Too Cool for School !

Beanie is worn daily on long morning speed walks, in cool weather

  • 5 stars out of 5
  • BC
  • verified buyer
  • verified reviewer
  • Rumson, NJ

My father-in-law loved this gift...

My father-in-law loved this unique gift. He is a die-hard Red Sox fan and lives in MA (frequent cold weather) so the hat will get a lot of use. He really liked the story behind how the hat is made. It was extra special since it was a 70th birthday gift!

Got questions? Find your answers here

  • MT

Can you make an Oakland A's beanie for the biggest fan in the world?

Verified reply from Jen

Hey there superfan! At this time, Oakland A's option is not available, however we can pass this info over to our team for the future.

  • Orange County, CA

So, 8.75", does that fit a 6' man? 5' woman? Medium build? Large build? Child?

Verified reply from Merve

These beanies are for adults and are one size fits all.

  • Salem, NH

How do you get the story on the hat that you purchased?

Verified reply from Michelle

Each hat is gift boxed with a story card and hologram number indicating the exact game the ball was used in.

  • MA

How does the sizing run on these hats? I see they are all handmade, but some heads are bigger than others. Any info? Thanks.

Verified reply from Valerie

These hats are 8.75" L x 8.75" W.

What makes this MLB Game-Used Baseball Beanie different from regular team hats?

This one-of-a-kind beanie is knit from actual wool yarn found inside MLB authenticated, game-used baseballs. Each hat uses 200+ yards of yarn from three continuous strands, making it a wearable piece of baseball history rather than just another team accessory.

How do I know which specific game my beanie's baseball came from?

Every beanie comes gift boxed with a story card and hologram number that indicates the exact game the baseball was used in. This authentication proves your hat contains yarn from a real MLB game, making it a true collectible.

Is this beanie actually warm enough for cold weather at games?

Absolutely! The beanie is lined with cozy alpaca wool to keep you warm during those chilly extra innings. The 100% wool construction from the baseball yarn provides excellent insulation, making it both a conversation starter and a practical winter hat.

Can I choose which MLB team I want for my beanie?

Yes, you can choose your team when ordering. Each beanie is handcrafted in California by a single craftsman using game-used baseballs from your selected MLB team, so you'll get authentic yarn from your favorite team's actual games.

How should I care for this unique beanie to preserve its authenticity?

Hand wash your beanie and lay it flat to dry. Since it's made from authentic game-used baseball yarn and lined with alpaca wool, gentle care will help preserve both the materials and the historical significance of your one-of-a-kind piece.